विकिपीडिया वार्ता:विकिपरियोजना सीडी निर्माण

यह पृष्ठ विकिपीडिया:विकिपरियोजना सीडी निर्माण पन्ने के सुधार पर चर्चा करने के लिए वार्ता पन्ना है। यदि आप अपने संदेश पर जल्दी सबका ध्यान चाहते हैं, तो यहाँ संदेश लिखने के बाद चौपाल पर भी सूचना छोड़ दें।
कृपया अपने संदेशों पर हस्ताक्षर करें, चार टिल्ड डालकर(`~~~~`)। नए संदेशों को पुराने संदेशों के नीचे डालें। नया विषय शुरु करने के लिए यहाँ क्लिक करें। विकिपीडिया पर नए हैं? स्वागत! प्रश्न पूछें, उत्तर पाएँ।	सभ्य रहें पूर्वाग्रह न रखें व्यक्तिगत आक्षेप न करें नवागंतुकों का स्वागत करें

Selection criteria[संपादित करें]

What are the selection criteria of these articles? Articles are suggested without considering their importance or relevance. So, before listing any article on the page, please set some selection criteria, and suggest articles here. For initiative, I'm suggesting some articles from geography section (incomplete list).

Hi, as of now I have included all featured articles of hindi Wiki and many articles written by user:hunnjazal who have created extremely well artcles so far.plz don't hesitate to remove any non deserving article from the list.Final selected articles list is here.This list is only for our reference to make final list.if you want to share any suggestion to elect articles plz give your suggestions--Mayur ^{(talk•Email)} 14:42, 29 जुलाई 2011 (UTC)[उत्तर दें]

Mayur, with all due respect, you're misinterpreting a term featured article. These articles aren't even near to featured status, these are just in decent shape as compare to other. Selection procedure should depend upon the relevance and must consider worldwide view, most of the articles listed by you are India oriented, which is not good for an international encyclopedia. As I've already suggested above, we should list the articles section by section, so that peer review procedure could become easier. — Bill william compton^Talk 15:12, 29 जुलाई 2011 (UTC)[उत्तर दें]

Criteria is simple, article should be cited, comprehensive and well presented and the image's licence should be fine. ♛♚★Vaibhav Jain★♚♛ ^Talk ^Email 14:38, 29 जुलाई 2011 (UTC)[उत्तर दें]

All the reviewed pags are here. ♛♚★Vaibhav Jain★♚♛ ^Talk ^Email 14:42, 29 जुलाई 2011 (UTC)[उत्तर दें]

Criteria must also consider their importance to the global context. For this, as always, English Wikipedia can help us, criteria of en wiki:

Articles that give context (गरीबी for भारत में गरीबी)
GA+ articles of mid importance or higher
B-Class articles of high importance or higher
C-Class articles of high importance or higher
Start-Class articles, if they are part of a set or are essential. Additional Start-Class articles may be selected by the bot if they are found to score very highly on importance parameters.
Articles needed for completeness
Country subdivisions of major countries (for example, Australian states)

and, who reviewed those articles (mentioned by you in category), like why Prabhu Lal Bhatnagar is in the list, what makes him so important? The articles is c-class and has mid importance on en wiki, thus fails the criteria. — Bill william compton^Talk 15:12, 29 जुलाई 2011 (UTC)[उत्तर दें]

Hi, as I have already explained that this list is for our reference you can add more articles to this.There are 2 types of featured articles in hindi wiki see this and this--Mayur ^{(talk•Email)} 15:54, 29 जुलाई 2011 (UTC)[उत्तर दें]

Geography[संपादित करें]

देश

ऑस्ट्रेलिया
ब्राज़िल
कनाडा
चीन
फ्रांस
ग्रेट ब्रिटेन
जर्मनी

भारत
जापान
पाकिस्तान
पुर्तगाल
रूस
दक्षिण अफ्रीका
दक्षिण कोरिया
स्पेन

महाद्वीप

एशिया
अफ्रीका
यूरोप
उत्तरी अमेरिका
दक्षिण अमेरिका
अंटार्कटिका

Selection criteria[संपादित करें]

Geography[संपादित करें]

अब तक चुने गये लेख(Referenced List)[संपादित करें]